What do I do when a prospect goes quiet after I send a proposal?
How to follow up on a consulting proposal that got no response
Follow up a few days after you send it, and give them something easy to answer, like an offer to walk through it on a short call. Silence usually means it's stuck on their end, not that the answer is no. If a few follow-ups don't get a reply, it's fine to send a short note closing it out, and that note sometimes gets the reply the others didn't.
The short answer
There are lots of ordinary reasons a proposal goes quiet. Someone else has to sign off. The timing changed. The price raised a question they don't want to ask. Or it got buried under other work. Asking "Did you get a chance to look?" doesn't help with any of those.
What helps is an easy next step. A call to go over it, a question about who else is reviewing it, or a smaller first phase are all easier to accept than a whole proposal.
There's no set number of follow-ups. Two or three spread over a few weeks is plenty for most proposals. After that, you can let it rest.
How soon should I follow up after sending a proposal?
Two or three business days is a good rule of thumb. If you talked about a decision date on the call, wait until just after that date instead.
What should I say in the first follow-up?
Keep it short and offer something specific. Something like this works:
"Hi Dana, I wanted to make sure the proposal reached you. If it would help, I can walk you through the two options on a 15-minute call this week. Here's my calendar if a time works."
A call gives them a way to bring up doubts without having to write them down. If they're in another time zone, the calendar invite shows the call in their local time.
How do I know if they even opened it?
If you sent it as an attachment, you can't. Proposal tools usually show when it was opened and how many times.
That tells you a lot. If they never opened it, resend it and check that it didn't go to spam. If they opened it once, they looked but didn't decide, so offer the call. If they opened it several times, they're probably sharing it with someone, so ask who else is looking at it.
What if someone else has to approve it?
Just ask: "Is anyone else reviewing this with you?" Then make it easy for them. Offer a quick call with whoever signs off, or send a short summary they can forward: the problem, what you'll do, how long it takes and what it costs.
What if the price is the problem?
People rarely say the price is too high. They just stop replying. If you think that's what's going on, offer a smaller scope, not a lower rate. A first phase, fewer deliverables or a shorter engagement can all bring the number down.
Next time, you might try putting two or three options side by side in the proposal, so they're choosing between options and not just deciding yes or no.
Should a proposal have an expiration date?
It's a good idea for practical reasons. Your schedule fills up and your prices change. A "valid until" date makes that clear, and it gives you a natural reason to check in. Just pick a date that matches when you could start, so it doesn't come across as a pressure tactic.
How many times should I follow up?
There's no magic number. Two or three follow-ups over a few weeks is usually enough, with a little more space between each one. Past that, more messages tend to feel like pressure.
What should the last follow-up say?
Close it out politely and leave the door open. For example:
"Hi Dana, I haven't heard back, so I'm guessing the timing isn't right. I'll close this out for now. If things change, just reply here and we can start again."
A note like this sometimes gets the first reply in weeks, because it doesn't ask for anything and makes it easy to say no.
How do I remember to follow up?
Set the date for your first follow-up the same day you send the proposal. Put it wherever you'll see it: your calendar, a reminder app or your CRM.
In Opsette, the proposal can be linked to the lead, and you can set a follow-up date on the lead that turns into a reminder on that day. The proposal page also shows how many times the client has opened it.
A worked example
Here's one way it could go for a proposal you send on a Monday, valid for 30 days. Check whether it's been opened before each message.
- Monday: send the proposal with a one-line summary in the email.
- Thursday: offer a 15-minute call to go over the options.
- The next Tuesday: ask whether anyone else is reviewing it, and offer a summary they can forward.
- About three weeks in: send the closing note, and set a reminder to check in again next quarter.
You can write these the day you send the proposal and schedule them in Gmail. If they reply before one goes out, cancel the rest. Gmail moves a cancelled scheduled email back to your drafts.
How consultants handle this
A lot of consultants try not to send a proposal cold. They agree on a decision date at the end of the first call, send the proposal within a day or two, and book a short call to go over it together.
A quiet proposal isn't a lost cause, either. Budgets open back up, and something that didn't fit this quarter might fit the next one. That's why the closing note leaves the door open.
Frequently asked questions
Is it pushy to follow up on a proposal?
No. They asked for the proposal, so following up is part of the process. It only starts to feel pushy when every message asks the same thing.
Should I call or email?
Use whatever you've been using with them. If everything so far has been by email, a surprise phone call can feel like pressure.
Should I lower my price if they go quiet?
It's usually better to offer a smaller scope at your normal rate. Dropping the price for the same scope makes them wonder whether the first price was real.
What if they say "not right now"?
Ask when would be a better time, and set a follow-up date for then, with a note about your conversation.
How long should a proposal be valid?
Long enough for them to decide, and short enough that your schedule and prices still hold. Tie it to when you could start.