How consultants turn interested prospects into clients, from the first call to a signed proposal.
Write the proposal from what the prospect told you on the call: their problem in their words, what you'll do about it, how long it takes and what it costs. Before the call ends, agree on when they'll get the proposal and when you'll go over it together. A proposal that arrives within a day or two, with a short review call already booked, is easier to accept than one that shows up a week later with no next step.
Ask what made them reach out now, how things work today, what the problem is costing them, what they've tried, who else decides, and when they want it solved. Let them do most of the talking, and save budget and timing for after you understand the problem. Before the call ends, book the next step while you're both still there.
Send them a booking link. They see the times you're open, pick one, and the call shows up on both your calendars. If someone was introduced to you or is a senior contact, offering two times in an email still works fine, but for most people a link saves you both a few rounds of replies.
A spreadsheet can be enough when you're starting out and only have a few prospects. Where it falls short is follow-ups: a spreadsheet won't remind you when it's time to reach out to someone. When you start missing follow-ups, that's a good sign it's time for something more.
Send a short note that brings up something they told you, and give them an easy next step. A plain "just checking in" can work, but it gives them less to reply to. Space your follow-ups out, and it's fine to stop after a few and try again in a couple of months.
Ask enough to get ready for the first call: who they are, what they need help with, and when they'd like to start. Some consultants also ask about budget or what they've already tried, and that's fine as long as the form stays short. Detailed questions, like their systems or logins, can wait until the prospect becomes a client.
Follow up a few days after you send it, and give them something easy to answer, like an offer to walk through it on a short call. Silence usually means it's stuck on their end, not that the answer is no. If a few follow-ups don't get a reply, it's fine to send a short note closing it out, and that note sometimes gets the reply the others didn't.