How do I follow up with a prospect who showed interest and then went quiet?
How to follow up with a warm lead who stopped replying
Send a short note that brings up something they told you, and give them an easy next step. A plain "just checking in" can work, but it gives them less to reply to. Space your follow-ups out, and it's fine to stop after a few and try again in a couple of months.
The short answer
When someone who seemed interested goes quiet, it's usually not a no. Their week got busy, something more urgent came up, or they're not sure what the next step is. Your follow-up just needs to put the problem back in front of them.
The easiest way is to mention something they said and offer one small thing: a time to talk, a quick idea for their problem, or an answer to a question they asked. That gives them something to respond to, which a check-in doesn't.
Each time you send a follow-up, decide when the next one goes out. Without that date, the lead can go cold.
Why do interested prospects go quiet?
Usually for ordinary reasons. Their week filled up, a bigger problem landed on their desk, the person who controls the budget is out, or they aren't sure what to do next. Most of the time it's about timing, not about you.
What should I write instead of "just checking in"?
Something they can answer in a line. A few examples:
- "You mentioned onboarding was taking your team two weeks. Here's a one-page outline of how I'd shorten it."
- "Is the reporting problem still a priority this quarter, or has it moved?"
- "I have two openings next week if you'd like to keep talking. Here's my calendar."
How long should I wait before following up?
A few business days after your last message is a good start. Then wait a little longer each time, like a week, then two. That gives them room without letting the conversation drop.
How do I keep a warm lead from going cold?
Agree on the next step before the conversation ends. Something like "I'll send the outline Thursday, and we can talk the following week" gives both of you a date. Then put that date somewhere it'll remind you.
Leads often go cold right after a good call, when each side assumes the other will write first.
Should I follow up by email, phone or LinkedIn?
Start with however they've been talking to you. If a couple of emails get nothing, switching it up can help, like a short LinkedIn message or a call that mentions your email. Just don't send the same message everywhere on the same day.
How many times should I follow up before I stop?
Three or four is a reasonable place to stop, ending with a short note that says you'll stop reaching out for now. Don't delete them, though. Mark them as nurturing and check back in a few months with something new, like an idea that fits their problem.
What if they told me to reach out next quarter?
Take them at their word. Set a follow-up date for the first week of that quarter, with a note about what they wanted. When the day comes, you can open with their own words: "You said the second quarter would be a better time to look at reporting."
Can I add a quiet prospect to my newsletter?
Ask them first. A newsletter is marketing email, and the FTC's CAN-SPAM rules apply even when you're emailing other businesses. Each email needs your mailing address and a clear way to opt out, and you have 10 business days to honor an opt-out.
Asking tells you something too. If they say yes to the newsletter, they're still interested.
How do I track who I owe a follow-up?
Write down every message with its date, and give each prospect a next follow-up date. A spreadsheet can do this if you check it every day. A CRM can remind you when the date comes.
In Opsette, each lead has a history of your calls, emails and meetings, and any of them can have a follow-up date that turns into a reminder.
A worked example
Say a prospect had a good first call on a Tuesday and asked you to send an outline for fixing their onboarding. You sent it Wednesday. Then nothing. Here's one way to follow up:
- The next Monday: reply on the same thread. "Did the outline match what you had in mind, or should I adjust it?"
- A week later: send one new idea for their problem in a couple of sentences, and offer a 15-minute call.
- Two weeks after that: try LinkedIn, with a short message that mentions the outline.
- About three weeks later: send a closing note. "I'll stop following up for now. If onboarding becomes a priority again, just reply here."
Then mark them as nurturing and set one more date, about three months out. You can also write a follow-up ahead of time and schedule it in Gmail. If they reply first, cancel it, and Gmail puts it back in your drafts.
How consultants handle this
Consultants who work with small businesses get used to long silences. An owner can be interested in March and ready in June, once a busy season ends or their plans change.
That's why quiet prospects rarely get deleted. They move to a nurturing list with a date a few months out. When the date comes, the consultant writes with something new, not just a reminder of the old conversation.
Good follow-ups are written by hand and sent one at a time. People can tell a personal note from an automated sequence.
Frequently asked questions
Is it annoying to follow up more than once?
Not if each message offers something new and you give it a little more time between each one. It gets annoying when the same "any update?" shows up every few days.
Should I point out that they haven't replied?
It's better not to. Pointing out the silence puts them on the spot. Write as if the conversation is still open, because it is.
What subject line should I use?
Replying on the same thread is easiest, since your earlier conversation is right there. If you start a new email, use a subject that names their problem, like "Onboarding outline."
Does the day of the week matter?
Not much. A steady gap between messages and a real reason for each one matter more.
What if they reply months later?
Great. Look over your notes from the last conversation, and reply as if no time has passed.